A motor vehicle is often one of the largest purchases a person makes, but an accident, theft, or mechanical failure can leave the owner facing significant costs.
The Non-life Insurance Division of the National Financial Ombud Scheme (NFO) says consumers should understand that motor policies do not all provide the same protection. Choosing inappropriate cover may leave motorists responsible for costs they believed were insured.
“Understanding the different types of cover available is, therefore, essential for vehicle owners to make informed decisions, protect their assets, and avoid unpleasant surprises when submitting a claim,” said Edite Teixeira-McKinon, Lead Ombud of the NFO’s Non-life Insurance Division.
Different types of cover
The NFO highlighted six types of vehicle insurance available in South Africa:
- Comprehensive cover generally covers accidental damage, hail damage, fire, theft, and third-party liability, subject to the policy’s terms and conditions. A financier or bank will generally require this cover when a vehicle is financed.
- Third-party cover provides cover for liability arising from damage caused to another person’s property. Depending on the policy, it may also cover fire or theft of the insured vehicle. It does not cover accidental damage to the policyholder’s own vehicle.
- Top-up cover is intended to cover the shortfall that may arise when a financed vehicle is written off or stolen and not recovered, and the underlying insurance settlement is less than the amount outstanding to the financier. Cover remains subject to the policy’s terms and limits.
- Mechanical-breakdown cover covers the mechanical or electrical failure of specified vehicle components, as set out in the policy. It may be particularly relevant to older vehicles.
- Tyre-and-rim cover covers specified damage to a vehicle’s tyres and rims, subject to the policy conditions.
- Scratch-and-dent cover covers minor cosmetic damage, such as small dents and scratches, in accordance with the policy’s terms and conditions.
Teixeira-McKinon said a consumer’s choice of cover should take account of whether the vehicle is financed and its age.
Comprehensive cover may exclude mechanical breakdown
The importance of understanding the differences between types of cover was illustrated by a complaint submitted to the Non-life Insurance Division.
The policyholder claimed under his comprehensive policy for what he described as accident damage to his truck. When it assessed the claim, the insurer found that the damage arose from a mechanical breakdown, which the policy specifically excluded.
There was no evidence of accident damage to the truck, and the division upheld the insurer’s rejection of the claim.
Mechanical-breakdown policies specify which components are covered, and the limit of the insurer’s liability depends on the component that has failed.
Insurer may decide whether to repair or write off a vehicle
Teixeira-McKinon said another common misconception concerns how a policyholder is indemnified after an insured incident.
“Most policies give the insurer the sole election to determine whether the vehicle will be repaired or written off. This election, however, must be exercised reasonably, and the insurer often relies on an assessor’s findings when making this decision,” she said.
In one matter, a policyholder submitted a claim for damage to a stolen-and-recovered vehicle. He objected to the insurer’s decision to repair the vehicle because he argued that its value had depreciated following its recovery.
The insurer pointed out that the policy did not provide cover for depreciation in the vehicle’s value.
The Non-life Insurance Division considered the assessor’s report, the vehicle’s retail value at the time of the loss, and the repair costs. It agreed with the insurer’s decision to repair the vehicle.
Older vehicles may be uneconomical to repair
The division also receives complaints from policyholders who object to an insurer’s decision to write off a vehicle rather than repair it. Teixeira-McKinon said this occurs particularly with older vehicles and vehicles that have been paid off.
“The risk of driving an older vehicle lies in the increasing cost of the parts due to a lack of availability, which leads to an increase in the likelihood of the vehicle being declared uneconomical to repair following an incident,” she said.
“On the other hand, affordability becomes an issue for complainants when having to replace a vehicle that has been written off, and hence the resistance to this approach by some complainants.”
Top-up cover may not settle every amount owed
Complaints involving top-up policies often concern the settlement amount.
The NFO said these policies specify how an insurer’s liability is calculated. The settlement will usually exclude balloon payments, missed monthly instalments, excesses deducted from the underlying insurer’s settlement, accessories that were not specified under the underlying policy, and premiums for other policies paid through the vehicle-finance account.
Consumers should therefore check how the settlement is calculated and which amounts the top-up policy excludes.
Dispute over whether a vehicle should be written off
An insurer’s discretion to decide how a policyholder should be indemnified was considered in another NFO complaint that reached the independent Appeal Tribunal.
The policyholder claimed for damage to his vehicle after a third party spray-painted it. An assessor determined that the vehicle was uneconomical to repair. The estimated repair costs were R468 175, whereas the vehicle’s retail value at the time of the loss was R596 300. which meant that the cost of repairs exceeded the insurer’s write-off threshold.
The policyholder objected to the insurer’s decision to write off the vehicle. In his application to the NFO, he asked the division to declare the decision invalid and direct the insurer to make a cash payment based on the repair quotation obtained from his own service provider.
In response to questions from Moonstone, Teixeira-McKinon provided further details about the insurer’s write-off threshold and the three settlement options.
She said the insurer’s write-off threshold was 65%. The threshold was not stated in the policy documents but was determined in accordance with the insurer’s claims and underwriting practice.
“Besides the write-off threshold, which may vary from insurer to insurer, there are other factors that can lead to an insurer deciding to write off a vehicle instead of repairing it, such as the availability of parts and the duration of the repair process,” she said.
Teixeira-McKinon said the South African Insurance Association’s Code of Conduct provides guidelines for members when deciding whether to repair a vehicle or write it off as uneconomical to repair.
“Ultimately, the insurer must exercise its discretion reasonably in the given circumstances.”
The insurer offered the policyholder three options for settling the claim.
Under the first option, the vehicle would be written off. Teixeira-McKinon said the settlement would be based on the vehicle’s retail value at the time of the loss, taking into account the amount owing to the finance house and the applicable excess.
Under the second option, the insurer would have the vehicle repaired by its appointed service provider, subject to the applicable excess.
The third option allowed the policyholder to retain the damaged vehicle and arrange the repairs himself. The insurer would settle the vehicle’s retail value at the time of the loss, less its salvage value and the applicable excess.
Teixeira-McKinon said the salvage value in this case could have ranged from 40% to 65% of the vehicle’s retail value. The insurer applied 40%.
The third option also included underwriting requirements relating to the repairs. These would apply if the policyholder wanted the insurer to consider insuring the repaired vehicle again.
The policyholder initially declined the options. The Non-life Insurance Division issued a final ruling upholding the settlement options offered by the insurer, after which the policyholder applied for leave to appeal.
“The Appeal Tribunal agreed that the policy granted the insurer a discretion to decide the manner in which the complainant was to be indemnified in the event of a loss, including the insurer’s decision to repair the vehicle at a repairer of its choice, and it dismissed the insured’s application for leave to appeal the final ruling,” Teixeira-McKinon said.
The policyholder subsequently accepted the insurer’s cash offer, which allowed him to arrange for the vehicle to be repaired by his chosen repairer.
“The matter highlights the importance of understanding the terms of an insurance policy and recognising that the insurer may have the contractual right to determine how a claim is settled,” Teixeira-McKinon said.




