A life right can look like a secure arrangement – until the person who holds it dies. The surviving spouse may suddenly face questions about their right to remain in the home, while the monthly costs continue and the fate of the capital paid for the right comes into focus.
There is no automatic statutory right for a surviving spouse to remain in a retirement village when the life right was acquired in the deceased spouse’s name only. As Lara Sneddon, an associate in the dispute resolution practice at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr (CDH), explains, “the rights of surviving spouses in these circumstances will be determined by the wording of the agreement and the facts of each case”.
But the agreement does not stand alone. Sneddon says the statutory context of retirement housing has led courts to apply contractual law in a way that takes account of the protections intended for older people.
Section 7(1) of the Housing Development Schemes for Retired Persons Act regulates who may occupy land once a housing interest has been transferred. It provides that “no person other than a retired person or the spouse of a retired person may occupy the land to which that housing interest relates”, unless all the holders of housing interests in the scheme give written consent.
The High Court in Johannesburg considered this provision in NG Kerk Brackenhurst Aftreebehuising NWO v H.J.B. and Another (13 March 2026). It said the provision reflects the legislature’s recognition that occupation in retirement housing schemes ordinarily extends to the purchaser’s spouse.
The Court also drew on the Constitutional Court’s judgment in Harris N.O. and Others v Herold Gie and Broadhead Inc and Others. Although Harris concerned the protection of funds entrusted in retirement housing transactions, the Constitutional Court emphasised the legislation’s wider purpose: protecting older people who invest their resources in retirement housing and securing residential stability in old age. The NG Kerk court considered that purpose relevant when deciding disputes about occupation.
What the agreement says – and what it leaves out
The NG Kerk dispute turned on a common situation: a person buys a life right, later marries, and their new spouse moves into the unit. What happens when the life-right holder dies?
Ms Botha acquired her life right in 2010, when she was divorced. She married Mr Badenhorst in 2019, and he lived with her in the unit until her death on 4 September 2023. The retirement scheme knew he was living there and had tacitly accepted his occupation.
After Ms Botha died, the scheme sought to evict him because he was not named as her spouse in the life-right agreement. The contract defined a spouse as someone whose details appeared in the agreement, but it did not deal with a purchaser marrying after signing. Nor did it say that a surviving spouse would lose the right to occupy the unit if their details had not been formally added.
The scheme argued that the agreement should have been terminated and replaced when Ms Botha married. The Court rejected this: neither the agreement nor the scheme rules required a new contract.
In reaching its decision, the Court considered the agreement’s wording, context, and purpose, together with how the parties had conducted themselves. It found that the parties had not intended continued occupation by a spouse to depend solely on a formal amendment to the agreement.
Mr Badenhorst’s occupation was not unlawful simply because his details had not been added to the contract. That omission, on its own, was not enough to justify eviction.
The judgment leaves room for courts to recognise tacit terms that protect a surviving spouse’s occupation, even where the agreement does not expressly deal with the situation. But relying on that possibility is a risky approach when the issue can be addressed before a dispute arises.
Sneddon says, “the express language of the agreement is important”. Couples should pay particular attention to provisions that expressly prevent a surviving spouse from remaining in the unit after the life-right holder dies.
Anyone who buys a life right and later marries or enters a long-term partnership should ask the scheme how the agreement can be amended. The change should be recorded in writing, with an explicit provision for the partner’s right to remain if the life-right holder dies first.
When a scheme seeks to evict a surviving spouse
The Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act (PIE Act) provides another layer of protection, but it does not rule out eviction.
A property holder seeking an eviction order must establish that the occupant is an unlawful occupier, that they occupy the property without the owner’s express or tacit consent, and that eviction would be just and equitable in the circumstances.
As Sneddon puts it, “eviction is not a mechanical consequence of unlawful occupation”. A court must weigh the interests of the property holder and the occupier, taking account of constitutional considerations such as dignity and the need to prevent the unjustified loss of a home.
Section 4(7) of the PIE Act requires the court to consider whether alternative accommodation is available. It must also have special regard for the rights and needs of older people, children, people with disabilities and households headed by women.
Those considerations were central to the NG Kerk decision. Mr Badenhorst was 78, in poor health, and on a limited income. He had little ability to secure alternative accommodation, and the unit had been his home for several years. His occupation was not opportunistic; he was living there because he had married the woman who held the life right.
The Court weighed the likely hardship to Mr Badenhorst against the scheme’s financial and administrative prejudice. His continued occupation prevented the resale of the housing interest and delayed the winding-up of Ms Botha’s estate. The Court noted, however, that the eviction application had been brought by the scheme itself, not by the executor seeking to finalise the estate.
The Court found that eviction would impose significant hardship on an elderly, unwell person with limited means of finding somewhere else to live. On those facts, eviction would not be just and equitable.
Sneddon cautions that “the just and equitable enquiry is always fact-specific and will vary from case to case”. The judgment may assist a surviving spouse facing eviction, but it does not guarantee that the outcome will be the same in another dispute.
There is also the question of what happens when a surviving spouse can no longer afford the monthly levies or other costs associated with the unit.
The Act neither expressly permits nor prohibits a retirement village from terminating a life right because of unpaid levies or other costs. The agreement will determine whether non-payment amounts to a breach and what steps the scheme must take.
A scheme seeking to terminate occupation on this basis must prove the breach, follow the agreement’s notice requirements and allow the occupant the specified time to remedy it. If the breach continues, the scheme will have to bring eviction proceedings under the PIE Act.
The court would still need to decide whether eviction was just and equitable, taking account of the surviving spouse’s age, health and financial means. Sneddon says a court “may treat a scheme’s financial and administrative prejudice as a weaker consideration in this balancing exercise”.
CDH advises surviving spouses who are struggling financially to “engage with the scheme as soon as possible and seek legal advice before agreeing to vacate the premises”.
What a life right gives the holder
Sneddon describes a life right as a “right of occupation, not ownership”. It allows the holder to occupy a unit for their lifetime or for the lifetime of another person named in the contract, such as a spouse. The holder does not own the property and cannot treat it as an asset to sell or leave to someone in a will.
As Sneddon explains, the right is personal: it cannot be transferred or inherited and generally cannot be sold on the open market or bequeathed. When the relevant lifetime ends, the housing interest reverts to the seller or another person specified in the agreement. The holder’s estate will usually receive, at most, a refund.
The financial arrangements also differ from an outright property purchase. A life-right holder generally pays an upfront capital sum, often structured as a refundable, interest-free loan, as well as a monthly levy. The agreement determines whether the capital is refundable, who receives it and when.
The Act allows for a fixed or determinable sum to be paid by way of a loan or otherwise, in one amount or instalments, in addition to or instead of a levy. The amount may be refundable, in whole or in part, to the purchaser, another person or the estate of either. As Sneddon points out, whether capital is refunded after the surviving spouse dies, how much is paid and when it is paid all depend on the agreement.
She also draws attention to the protection provided by section 4A of the Act. A right of occupation ranks as a registered lease and takes priority over other rights, whether or not they have been registered or endorsed against the title deed, and regardless of when they were registered or endorsed.
Frail care is another issue clients should clarify before signing. Sneddon notes that although the Act deems a facility maintained mainly for the care of debilitated people to be a home for the aged, the legislation does not expressly deal with what happens to a retirement unit when a resident moves into frail care. The relevant provisions refer to the Aged Persons Act, which has since been repealed and replaced by the Older Persons Act. Whether a resident can retain the unit or must give it up will depend on the life-right agreement and the scheme rules.
The checks to make before a client signs
The initial capital payment is only one part of the commitment. Advisers need to establish what clients will pay over time, what services they will receive, and what happens when their circumstances change.
Sneddon recommends checking:
- The purchase price or capital sum.
- All applicable levies, including the amounts payable for at least the next two years.
- The scheme’s estimated budget for the next three years, and who will be liable for it.
- Any exit or refurbishment fees.
- Which facilities, frail care and nursing care are included or available.
- Whether amounts paid are refundable, when a refund would be made and what deductions may apply.
- What happens to the surviving spouse’s right of occupation.
Clients should also compare a life right with buying a retirement property outright and with other accommodation options. Ownership allows a person to sell, bequeath, or mortgage the property, but also makes them responsible for maintenance and care arrangements. A life right carries different financial and practical obligations.
Comparing the total costs, including levies, over the client’s expected lifespan can help establish which arrangement better fits their lifestyle needs and financial circumstances. CDH also recommends obtaining independent legal advice on a proposed agreement before signing.
Existing agreements need attention too
The questions do not end once a client has moved into a retirement village. An agreement signed years earlier may no longer reflect the holder’s circumstances.
Sneddon advises checking that both the life-right holder and the scheme have countersigned copies of the latest agreement, including any amendments. The client’s current marital circumstances should also match the details recorded in the contract.
If the holder married or entered a long-term partnership after signing, the change should have been formally recorded or communicated to the scheme in writing. Advisers should encourage clients to obtain written acknowledgement from the scheme and, where possible, a signed addendum.
The NG Kerk case shows the difficulties that can arise when the agreement and a resident’s circumstances do not match. The scheme knew about Mr Badenhorst’s occupation, and its acceptance of that arrangement carried weight in the court’s assessment. Written records of any such communication and acceptance are important.
To avoid similar uncertainty, Sneddon says the agreement should include the full particulars of the spouse or partner, together with “a clear statement that occupation continues after the first spouse’s/right holder’s death”.
It should also spell out what happens to the unit and any capital paid when the life-right holder dies, and when the surviving spouse eventually dies.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for information purposes only and does not constitute legal or financial advice. The rights and obligations of life-right holders and their surviving spouses will depend on the terms of the relevant agreement and the circumstances of each case. Readers should seek independent legal advice before entering into or making decisions about a life-right agreement.




