The rules governing provisional tax estimates and payments have been tightening over the years and recent proposals further increase the risk of incurring harsh penalties.
A proposed change to the Tax Administration Act relates to underestimation penalties of 20% even if a provisional taxpayer estimated his taxable income for the year of assessment within the prescribed threshold.
“A correct estimate on the IRP6 would no longer, on its own, protect a taxpayer who fails to pay the required amount in full within one month of the payment deadline,” says Joon Chong, tax partner at Webber Wentzel.
Provisional tax is income tax paid in two instalments during the year of assessment. It is based on an estimate of what a taxpayer expects to earn in that year.
“I understand the policy objective. Taxpayers should not be able to avoid an underestimation penalty simply by putting an acceptable estimate on an IRP6 without paying the provisional tax that follows from that estimate,” she says.
However, the amendment potentially goes further than addressing deliberate non-payment. A taxpayer may have estimated his taxable income correctly but, because of genuine cash-flow difficulties, fail to make the full payment within one month of the due date.
“On our interpretation of the proposed wording, that taxpayer could then face both the existing late-payment consequences and an underestimation penalty, notwithstanding that its estimate of taxable income was within the acceptable range,” Chong says.
That is a significant change because it effectively links the accuracy of an estimate to whether the resulting tax was actually paid, she adds. Timely payment of the provisional tax relating to an estimate would be required before the taxpayer can rely on that estimate for purposes of the underestimation penalty.
According to her reading the new proposal will changes what counts as the final or last estimate for purposes of the underestimation penalty – if the required second provisional tax payment is not made in full within one month of its due date.
She believes the amendment is likely to be enacted as drafted. “Taxpayers need to focus not only on getting the provisional tax estimate right, but also on ensuring that the tax is actually paid on time and on documenting the reasons carefully where it cannot be.”
The amendment will come into effect once the Tax Administration Laws Amendment Act is gazetted. According to Chong, this could be at the end of December 2026 or January next year, applying to the second provisional estimates due at the end of January or February 2027.
Increased threshold and late payments
Another amendment tabled before Parliament will increase the R1-million taxable income threshold to R1.8m. If a taxpayer’s taxable income is above R1.8m for the tax year, the estimated income for the second provisional tax (at the end of February for a February year-end) must be within 80% of the actual income for the year.
The increased threshold will benefit provisional taxpayers by enabling those earning less than R1.8m to use a basic amount based on their previous assessment.
Provisional tax definition
During a Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill workshop hosted by National Treasury last week, the way in which taxpayers, particularly small and less knowledgeable taxpayers, are expected to determine their provisional tax status came under fire.
Getting it wrong may result in potential late payments and underestimation penalties, Carmen Westermeyer, on behalf of the South African Institute for Chartered Accountants (SAICA), pointed out during the workshop.
She noted that this affects vulnerable taxpayers who do not earn huge amounts in terms of taxable income outside remuneration. It may be someone renting out a granny flat for R5 000 a month or a retiree receiving a once-off lump sum, pushing them over the annual threshold of R30 000 to qualify as a provisional taxpayer.
If they did not register as a provisional taxpayer, made a first payment on the estimated income for the year in August, they are in for a penalty surprise when they receive their final assessment from the South African Revenue Service.
Sumaya Khaki, project director at SAICA, said there must be a “safe harbour” for people who fall into the provisional taxpayer category for the first time and do not realise it. This also applies to a taxpayer who falls outside the net the following year and files their annual return as a provisional taxpayer.
Penalty and interest waiver
Westermeyer requested that SARS and National Treasury clarify the trigger for provisional taxpayer status. The definition currently creates a “prospective compliance obligation” on a taxpayer who may be capable of determining their status only at the end of the year of assessment.
“A regime that requires taxpayers to predict future facts before they can know whether they are subject to an obligation creates uncertainty and may be vulnerable to legal challenge,” she said.
SARS noted the concerns and proposed potential solutions such as a rolling three-year window where the provisional taxpayer stays out of the net for three years if they do not qualify any longer in year three.
Amanda Visser is a freelance journalist who specialises in tax and has written about trade law, competition law, and regulatory issues.
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the writer and are not necessarily shared by Moonstone Information Refinery or its sister companies. The article is intended for general educational purposes and does not constitute financial advice, investment advice, legal advice, or a regulatory compliance opinion.




