“The greatest threat to profitability, it seems, is not just rising electricity tariffs, but the possibility that energy-intensive businesses are paying more than they should in the first place.”
That is the concern raised by Mila Vicquery, general manager of Syntiro and head of sustainability at Energy Partners, in an opinion piece examining the financial risks of inaccurate electricity tariffs and billing.
Her warning comes as the National Energy Regulator of South Africa (NERSA) faces questions in the High Court in Pretoria over electricity tariffs it approved for five municipalities for the 2025/26 financial year.
On 9 November, NERSA admitted that the tariffs approved for Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, Nelson Mandela Bay, Emfuleni, and Madibeng were unlawful. The tariff applications contained significant calculation errors, and the regulator approved the figures without adequately checking them, according to Moneyweb’s report on the court proceedings.
The Court heard that businesses in Nelson Mandela Bay paid 76% more for electricity during 2025/26 than it cost the municipality to provide the service, as reported by Daily Maverick.
The dispute has moved beyond whether the tariffs were lawful. Judge RG Tolmay is considering how customers who overpaid should be compensated. The applicants have proposed retrospective credits to electricity accounts, with interest if repayment is delayed, or temporary alternative tariffs while NERSA recalculates the charges.
There is also disagreement over who should receive relief. Mpact has suggested limiting adjustments to the companies that brought the case, while NERSA argues that corrections should apply to all electricity users in the affected municipalities. Ekurhuleni has said it cannot afford to refund customers, and NERSA has asked the Court to consider phasing in tariff corrections over several years.
The judge has also raised the possibility of appointing an independent expert to establish the extent of the overcharging and help determine the credits due to affected customers. She has asked the legal teams to consider ways of ensuring that any eventual order is implemented.
The latest case is not the first time NERSA and municipalities have been taken to court over electricity tariffs. In an earlier matter, the High Court set aside NERSA’s approval of the 2024/25 tariffs for Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, Madibeng, and Msunduzi. The regulator was ordered to redetermine the tariffs but had missed the deadline to do so, according to Moneyweb. In Msunduzi, businesses were still waiting for credits arising from an earlier court order.
Vicquery’s concern extends beyond the municipalities named in the latest case.
“This raises a fundamental question for businesses already grappling with escalating operating costs: if regulatory approval cannot guarantee the validity of electricity tariffs, how confident can businesses be that their electricity accounts are accurate?”
The cost of getting it wrong
Electricity is one of the largest operating expenses for South African businesses, particularly in manufacturing, mining, agriculture, and other energy-intensive sectors.
“While successive tariff increases have placed considerable pressure on profitability, inaccurate or inflated billing introduces another layer of financial exposure that can erode margins, either very suddenly or more quietly over time,” says Vicquery.
Municipal tariff applications often rely on calculations prepared by consultants. Vicquery argues that these calculations may be accepted without enough scrutiny, partly because NERSA does not have the resources to review them in detail beyond the standard tariff increase proposed by the municipality.
“If municipal tariff restructuring brings about an 18% cost increase instead of the 8% initially applied for, there is no body currently running simulation analysis on the actual cost increase for the consumers,” she says.
The amount on an electricity account depends on more than the tariff increase. Tariff classifications, consumption patterns, maximum demand, time-of-use structures, and municipal billing methods also affect what a business pays.
Businesses need to check that the correct tariff classification has been applied, that meter readings reflect actual consumption, and that demand and time-of-use charges have been calculated correctly. An incorrect allocation, inaccurate reading, or misapplied charge can leave a company paying substantially more than it should.
A relatively small discrepancy can mean a significant amount of money when an industrial operation is spending millions of rands on electricity every year.
Wheeling adds to the billing challenge
The growth of electricity wheeling brings another set of costs for businesses to track.
Wheeling allows a business to buy electricity from an independent producer and use the existing transmission and distribution networks to get that power to its premises. It can give companies access to competitively priced renewable energy through long-term power purchase agreements (PPAs).
But the price of the electricity itself is only one part of the calculation. Businesses must also account for network charges, use-of-system fees for transmission and distribution, electricity bought from utilities when contracted generation is insufficient, and the cost of balancing supply with actual consumption.
Vicquery says the changing energy market is creating “both opportunity and risk for local businesses”.
Large electricity users need to reconcile these different charges and supply arrangements to establish whether an alternative procurement strategy is delivering the expected financial benefit.
More than a monthly electricity bill
Businesses have traditionally treated electricity as an operating expense, concentrating on reducing consumption and improving energy efficiency. Vicquery says they now need to check the financial accuracy of their energy accounts as closely as they monitor consumption.
Unexpected municipal charges can surface after the financial year has closed, affecting the accuracy of financial statements and potentially a company’s share price. Identifying discrepancies before year-end also gives finance teams an opportunity to make appropriate provisions and accruals, rather than having to deal with unexpected costs after the fact.
Her proposed scope for financial oversight extends beyond municipal accounts to on-site generation performance, wheeling reconciliation, curtailment exposure, and renewable energy credit compliance across every active PPA. These costs and obligations need to be monitored in real time.
The task is more demanding for companies with operations in several locations. Different municipalities may have different tariff structures and billing practices, while businesses using a combination of municipal electricity, wheeling, and on-site generation have several supply arrangements to reconcile.
Businesses need to be able to model their electricity costs, compare information from different sources, and identify discrepancies before they turn into costly disputes. That means understanding what each site should be paying, checking the charges against the applicable tariffs and supply agreements, and making sure the figures are reflected accurately in financial reporting.
“Ultimately, NERSA’s recent admission should serve as a wake-up call for corporate South Africa. As the electricity market becomes increasingly decentralised and complex, businesses can no longer afford to manage only how much electricity they consume. They must also take back control of billing and tariff accuracy.”




