Audit firms face new levy and tougher compliance consequences

Posted on — Leave a comment

Audit firms could be required to pay a levy of up to 1% of the audit fees they charged during the preceding calendar year under draft legislation published by National Treasury.

The levy would be established by the Draft Audit Service Levy Bill, while the Draft Financial Matters Amendment Bill would amend the Auditing Profession Act to provide for its administration and collection and link firms’ compliance with certain reporting and payment obligations to their registration. The latter Bill also proposes wider changes to auditor independence, inspections, disciplinary processes, and regulatory oversight.

National Treasury published both Bills for public comment under Government Notice 8182 in Government Gazette 55740 on 13 November 2026.

The Financial Matters Amendment Bill would also amend laws affecting banks, insurers, co-operative financial institutions, supervised entities, and deposit insurance. These non-audit provisions are addressed this article: Regulators could make financial firms pay to verify their submissions.

Levy based on the preceding calendar year

The Audit Service Levy Bill distinguishes between the “levy period” and the “levy year”.

The levy period would be the calendar year preceding the commencement of the levy year. A levy year would run from 1 April to 31 March of the following year.

A firm’s levy could not exceed 1% of the audit fees it charged during the levy period. Disbursements and value-added tax would be excluded from the calculation, and the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors (IRBA) would determine the applicable percentage.

At the maximum rate, a firm that charged R10 million in qualifying audit fees during the preceding calendar year would incur a levy of R100 000. This is an illustration based on the statutory ceiling. The Bill does not indicate what percentage IRBA intends to impose.

The Financial Matters Amendment Bill would remove IRBA’s power to prescribe fees for inspections or reviews. According to the memorandum accompanying the Bill, this is because the Board would be funded through the proposed levy.

The Board would continue to receive funding from prescribed fees, other lawful sources, including sanctions, and money appropriated by Parliament.

Returns, statements, and payment

At the start of a levy year, a firm would have to submit a return in the manner prescribed by IRBA.

The return would have to specify all audit services rendered during the levy period and the corresponding audit fees charged, excluding disbursements and VAT. IRBA would determine the levy and issue a written statement confirming the amount payable. The firm would have 30 days after receiving the statement to pay the levy.

The Financial Matters Amendment Bill would require the levy and accrued interest to be paid into a designated account in IRBA’s name and under its control, approved by National Treasury. It would also provide that any overpayment of a levy or interest is a debt owed and payable by the Board to the firm.

If a firm failed to submit its return timeously, IRBA would have to use the firm’s last submitted return to determine the levy. This would not relieve the firm of liability for the actual fees, arrears, or interest imposed by the Board.

The levy Bill appears to contain a drafting error in this provision. Section 3(5) refers to the return envisaged in subsection (4), although the return is required by subsection (3). Subsection (4) concerns the written statement issued by the Board.

Different approaches to late-payment interest

The Bills take different approaches to interest on an unpaid levy.

The Audit Service Levy Bill provides that late payments will attract interest at the rate determined under section 80(1)(b) of the Public Finance Management Act. It does not specify the same 30-day period after the due date provided for in the Financial Matters Amendment Bill.

The Financial Matters Amendment Bill would provide that interest applies to the portion of a levy remaining unpaid 30 days after the due date. It refers to the rate prescribed under the Prescribed Rate of Interest Act.

It is not clear from the drafts how these provisions are intended to operate together. The difference affects both the apparent starting point for interest and the statutory rate referred to.

Newly registered firms and exemptions

A firm registered after the start of a levy year would first become liable in the following levy year. The levy Bill says its liability would be calculated on all audit fees “generated” from its registration date.

The main calculation provision refers instead to fees “charged”. The Bill does not explain whether the different terminology is intended to be significant.

IRBA could exempt a firm from paying the levy in circumstances prescribed by the Board. The Bill does not identify the firms that could qualify or the process through which an exemption would be obtained.

Registration consequences for non-compliance

The Financial Matters Amendment Bill would link firms’ return and payment obligations to their continued registration.

IRBA could cancel a firm’s registration if it failed to submit a return required under the Auditing Profession Act or the proposed Audit Service Levy Act by the due date set by the Board. It could also cancel the registration of a firm under provisional or final liquidation.

Cancellation would not extinguish fees, levies, arrears, or interest imposed for the period during which the firm was registered.

The registration of a partnership, sole proprietor, or company would automatically lapse if it no longer complied with the registration requirements in section 38(1), or if it failed to pay a prescribed fee, levy, or accrued interest within the period prescribed by IRBA.

The Bill would also introduce a definition of “good standing”. A registered auditor would have to comply with all registration eligibility and continuity requirements, have no outstanding returns, fees, levies, or other financial obligations to IRBA, and not be subject to any ongoing disciplinary or enforcement sanction or suspension that had not been fully discharged.

A firm would be prohibited from knowingly employing a registered auditor who was not in good standing with IRBA.

Independence and non-audit services

The Financial Matters Amendment Bill would amend the conflict-of-interest provisions applying to registered auditors.

A registered auditor could not audit an entity’s financial statements if the auditor had or previously had a conflict of interest. This would include prescribed circumstances in which the auditor or audit firm provides or has provided services other than auditing to the entity.

The draft does not identify the affected services or the period during which their provision would disqualify the auditor. These details would have to be prescribed by IRBA.

The Bill would also empower IRBA to prescribe the duration for which an audit firm could accept appointment by an entity. The proposed amendment identifies enhanced auditor independence and audit quality as its objectives but does not specify the permitted duration of appointment.

New disclosure obligations

An individual registered auditor would have to notify IRBA of any change in contact details within 30 days.

A registered auditor would also have to notify IRBA in writing within 10 days of becoming aware of a relevant pending or completed investigation, or its outcome, by:

  • an accredited professional body;
  • another regulator, including an international regulator; or
  • a law-enforcement agency.

The investigation would have to be relevant to the person’s role as an auditor.

Registered auditors would also have to provide information or returns requested by IRBA annually or whenever required. A firm’s failure to submit a return required by this provision could lead to cancellation of its registration.

Listed-entity audit inspection findings would be made public

IRBA, or a person it authorised, would have to inspect or review at least once every three years the firm of a registered auditor that audits a listed entity. IRBA would have to publish the results and findings of these inspections.

It could also publish the outcomes, results, and findings of other inspections or reviews if it considered publication necessary and in the public interest.

Where a registered auditor was found guilty of improper conduct, the published outcome would have to include:

  • the auditor’s name;
  • the audit firm at which the auditor practised when the conduct occurred;
  • a summary of the charges;
  • the finding and sanction; and
  • any cost order.

Equivalency status for foreign audit regulators

The Bill would empower IRBA to assess whether a foreign audit regulator’s system met the proposed requirements for equivalency status.

The Board could confer equivalency status following an application or on its own initiative. It would have to review an equivalency determination at least once every seven years.

IRBA could withdraw the status after notifying the foreign audit regulator and giving it between 30 and 60 days to make representations. It would have to publish the outcomes of equivalency assessments and subsequent reviews.

According to the memorandum, the system is intended to mitigate market risk, protect investors, improve transparency, and enable reciprocity arrangements with foreign audit regulators.

Sanctions could be enforced as civil judgments

A sanction imposed by the enforcement committee or a disciplinary hearing panel would have the effect of a civil judgment. A warrant of execution could be issued once 30 days had elapsed from the date the sanction was imposed, provided no application for judicial review had been made to a court of competent jurisdiction.

Specified decisions could be taken to the proposed Financial Services and Audit Tribunal for reconsideration. An application for reconsideration would not suspend the decision unless the Tribunal ordered otherwise.

At least two members of the renamed Tribunal would have to possess at least 10 years’ auditing experience and previously have been registered auditors. A panel hearing an auditing matter would have to include at least one member with those qualifications.

Changes to reportable-irregularity procedures

The Bill would amend the second-report process following the reporting of a reportable irregularity.

The second report would have to be submitted as soon as reasonably possible, but no later than 30 days after the first report was sent to IRBA.

The second report could state that the reporting auditor had been removed in contravention of section 45(7) of the Auditing Profession Act and was unable to submit the report. On receiving a report containing that statement, IRBA would have to provide the appropriate regulator with the report and any supporting documents that accompanied it.

Wider information-sharing powers

The Bill would broaden the circumstances in which IRBA could disclose information to appropriate domestic and international regulators.

Disclosure could be made for inspections, investigations, disciplinary or enforcement processes, and other regulatory functions. IRBA could also disclose information where this was necessary to perform its functions or protect the public in its dealings with registered auditors.

Information could also be disclosed to international audit regulators or recognised international forums for benchmarking, research, and educational purposes.

Governance and standard-setting changes

IRBA members’ maximum terms would increase from three to five years. The maximum terms of the chairperson and deputy chairperson would also increase from three to five years.

The committee for auditing standards would gain:

  • a representative of the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission;
  • an advocate or attorney with at least 10 years’ legal experience; and
  • a member of civil society.

The committee for auditor ethics could assist the Board in influencing international ethics pronouncements by commenting on consultative documents and nominating representatives to international standard-setting committees.

Commencement and public comments

If enacted, both measures would take effect on dates determined by the President by proclamation in the Gazette.

Written comments may be submitted to CommentDraftLegislation@treasury.gov.za by 31 January 2027.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *