
FST reinforces limits on Adjudicator’s jurisdiction over employer-held disability claims
The ruling set aside directions concerning an employer-held benefit that the retirement fund was not authorised to administer under its registered rules.

The ruling set aside directions concerning an employer-held benefit that the retirement fund was not authorised to administer under its registered rules.

Le nkqubo yazisa ukufikelela okulinganiselweyo kwinxalenye yemali eyongiweyo, kodwa ayizange itshintshe izithintelo ekudala zikhona zokutsalwa kwemali ezisebenza kwii-akhawunti zomhlalaphantsi (ii-RA).

The Adjudicator upheld a fund’s reliance on affordability requirements but cautioned it about poor service delivery and delayed communication.

The determination highlights the need for independent judgment, proper investigation, and clear reasons when allocating benefits among dependants.

An IRFA panel says trustees need clear escalation processes and persistent oversight to turn section 13A compliance into meaningful recovery action.

The Pension Funds Adjudicator plans to use its powers more assertively against employers, funds, and responsible persons who ignore complaints or fail to co-operate.

The Tribunal found that evidence of tax non-residence must be assessed against the legislation, with clear reasons given when it is considered insufficient.

The Tribunal says the Adjudicator shifted the evidentiary goalpost over three determinations and passively accepted uncorroborated allegations.

The Adjudicator orders a fresh investigation after finding that the fund had not adequately verified an alleged cohabiting partner’s claim.

Continuous cohabitation and joint bank accounts are relevant but not decisive when trustees assess whether a claimant was a permanent life partner.

The ruling found sufficient prima facie evidence for withholding but did not determine whether Karabo Ramela committed fraud or caused the claimed losses.

The decision clarifies when prior civil proceedings may prevent the Pension Funds Adjudicator from investigating a complaint over withheld benefits.

Although the retirement fund misapplied section 37C, the OPFA found the same outcome was equitable after applying the Constitutional Court’s guidance.

The retirement fund was not entitled to pay the benefit into the estate because it only learned of the member’s death more than a year later.

The Adjudicator conflated jurisdiction with enforcement and overlooked the potential personal-liability provisions in the PFA.

The Tribunal says membership could end only in accordance with the fund’s rules, and WhatsApp exchanges did not amount to a valid withdrawal.

Nearly nine years after the claim was lodged, the fund still could not confirm whether the benefit had been allocated or paid.