
Offshore CFD complaint turns on role of local FSP
The Tribunal found no evidence that the provider advised the investor on the loss-causing trades or breached its intermediary obligations.

The Tribunal found no evidence that the provider advised the investor on the loss-causing trades or breached its intermediary obligations.

The ruling set aside directions concerning an employer-held benefit that the retirement fund was not authorised to administer under its registered rules.

The judgment distinguishes jurisdiction over a foreign company from jurisdiction over its offshore conduct, while leaving the Competition Act’s broader reach for another case.

Offshore companies are not beyond the Competition Commission’s reach, but a local connection alone will not be enough to bring them before South African competition authorities.

The decision clarifies when prior civil proceedings may prevent the Pension Funds Adjudicator from investigating a complaint over withheld benefits.

The decision highlights the distinction between punishing misconduct and compensating consumers who claim to have suffered losses.

The Adjudicator conflated jurisdiction with enforcement and overlooked the potential personal-liability provisions in the PFA.

The SCA rules that section 127(8) of the NCA empowers Magistrates’ Courts to hear these claims, but it does not bar High Court proceedings.

Tribunal confirms that only benefits administered by a registered fund fall under the Pension Funds Adjudicator’s jurisdiction.

Expanding the Office’s mandate to include disputes involving advice will enhance member protection, but there are concerns over jurisdictional overlaps and operational costs.

As a result of the declarator, the High Court ordered the Tribunal to revisit its decision regarding the R50m fine imposed on Viceroy Research.

Most complaints to the NFO went to the Non-life Division, whose interventions yielded R107m in quantifiable benefits for policyholders.

The ruling highlights the need for the timely communication of beneficiary changes in life insurance policies.

Enforcement of the Adjudicator’s orders must proceed where the employer-municipality resides and where the unpaid contributions arose.

The Authority invites interested parties to participate in High Court proceedings that will decide whether it may impose penalties on foreign individuals without physically serving documents in South Africa.

National labour forums have jurisdiction when the employment contract is governed by South African law and connected to a local public entity.

SCA also finds that the High Court should not have granted punitive cost orders against the fund.